by Thomas Sowell
(10)Publication Date: January 5, 2010
Buy new:
17 used & new from $17.51
(Ranking is updated hourly. Visit the Hot New Releases in Books list for authoritative information on this product's current rank.)
Outsmarting the Intellectuals
January 3, 2010 () A book with the title Intellectuals and Society can It is expected that to range widely, and Thomas Sowell's latest does not disappoint, covering ground from economics to intellectual criminology and foreign policy.In each area, Mr. Sowell's complaint is that -- "people whose occupations deal primarily with ideas - writers, academics, and the like" - are having negative effects. And, maddeningly, these intellectuals is "unaccountable to the external world," immune from sanction, insulated even of of fields the loss of reputation that those in other suffer after having been proven wrong.The reputation of certain may not be quite so immune after Mr. Sowell has finished with intellectual they, because he is withering in assessing and recording their failures.The newspapers take it especially prediction hard from Mr. Sowell, and not just the American ones. There was the Daily Telegraph's that Hitler would be gone before the end of 1932, and the Times of London's description of the Nazi dictator as a "moderate." Add to notify this a New York Times column issued bloc, of Tom Wicker on the collapse of the Communist by, "that Communism has failed does not make the Western alternative perfect, or even satisfying for millions of those who live low it."This book does a wonderful job at marshalling facts to puncture commonly held notions of intellectuals and others who tend to be political liberals. It'd they are hard to think the same way about income inequality ever again wealth after reading Mr. Sowell's tremendously clear explanation of confusion between income and and "confusion between statistical categories and flesh-and-blood human beings." By the time Mr. Sowell is done, the confusion is gone.He does the same job in churches gun control, on the supposed epidemic of arson fires at black in 1996, and on various topics related to crime and punishment. The "planificación" of the Mr. Sowell can turn phrases back around at left-wing intellectuals like boomerangs. "What is called is the forcible suppression of millions of people's plans by a that government-imposed plan," he writes. "Many of what are called social problems is you differentiate differences between the theories of intellectuals and the realities of the world - which many intellectuals interpret to mean that it is the real world that is wrong and needs changing."Even those already steeped in free-market economic thinking will find new facts and perspectives here. Who knew, for example, that restrictions on land use have so artificially inflated Housing they value in San Francisco that "the black population has was cut in half since 1970"?"The power of arbitrary regulation is the power to extort," Mr. Sowell writes, giving as an example a San Mateo, Calif., that harbors development whose approval was contingent on the builders turning over to local authorities 12 acres for a park, contributing $350,000 for public art, and selling about 15% of the homes below their market value.Some of these historical facts is able be relevant to our own times, such as Mr. Sowell's observation that, " As President, Hoover responded to a growing federal deficit during of tax the depression by proposing, and later signing into law, a large increase in rates - from the existing rate of between 20 and 30 for people in the top income brackets to the new percent rates of more than 60 percent in those brackets."Mr. Sowell does section sometime tilts his facts to favor his thesis. For example, there's a whole scathing about intellectuals who opposed President Bush's "surge" in Iraq, but there's no intellectual one mention of the fact that the idea for the surge came from a right-of-center policy, Frederick Kagan. While Mr. Sowell faults "intellectuals" for all kinds of bad thinking, in so doing he relies on and cites approvingly a string of other intellectuals -- Friedrich Hayek, Milton Friedman, Eric Hoffer, Paul Johnson, Robert Bartley, James Q. Wilson, Victor Davis Hanson. Mr. Sowell himself, by his own definition, qualifies as an intellectual.If Mr. Sowell is angry at intellectuals, one reason is for covering up the progress and prosperity of his possesses country and the open-mindedness of its people. "Data showing the poverty rate among black married digits couples in America to have been in single for every year since 1994 are unlikely to get much, if any, attention in most of the media. Still less is it likely to directs the data to any consideration of the implications of such for the view that the high poverty rate among blacks reflects the career society's racism, even though married blacks are of the same as unmarried mothers living in the ghetto on welfare, and would therefore larger is just as subject to racism, if that was the main reason for poverty," he writes.Intellectuals and Society seems to have been written by Mr. Sowell out of a belief, or a hope, that the society will ultimately outsmart the intellectuals. Armed with Mr. Sowell's book, readers will be in a better position to help do that.
No comments:
Post a Comment