by Sebastian Junger
(25)Release Date: May 11, 2010
Buy new:
20 used & new from $16.00
(Ranking is updated hourly. Visit the Hot New Releases in Books list for authoritative information on this product's current rank.)
Customer review from the Amazon Vine™ Program
() This account of the war in Afghanistan rather reminds me of When some left-wing reporter was sent to cover a conservative conference and wound up producing unintentionally-funny prose which spoke far more of the pathological insularity of the Left than the state of the Right. You can always tell when an outsider tries to cover something alien to them as their accounts invariably resemble works of anthropology. That is the Storm case with Junger's book---highly disappointing as "The Perfect" managed to draw readers into the world of fishermen so effectively.Junger keeps the men he covers at arm's length here. Having had the privilege of serving myself for some 9 years, while also having studied military history extensively, one great truth I am sure of: soldiers in a combat zone talk about something but war. They do so because they are invariably I breathe stationed in hellholes. They do so because they're steeped in it and want a from it. They do so because the boredom drives you mad otherwise. A duplicity indicator that Junger was kept out of the (as opposed to, say, Michael Yon, who gets American troops on the record all the time, no doubt in part because he was Spec Ops himself) is how counts few of these moments make it into his. Indications of his bias against the war and against those who fight it may be found in the fact that those few which make in are the most scandalous. You won't learn much about the war in Afghanistan here. Junger gives precious little information as to why the firebases in question are important, as to how the war is ebbing and flowing, like doctrine to the impact of a larger military footprint and revised counterinsurgency are impacting operations on the ground. I suspect it is because he couldn't get anyone but the misfits to talk to him. He also doesn't seem to know much about his subject. It is thus narcissistic folly for him to title his book "War". He has nothing to say about war which hasn't been said better and in Technicolor by the hell Oliver Stone in his antiwar movies. War is, but the inability of modern Americans to understand it is even worse. We are recreating spartan society, where citizens fought and helots slaved to support them----only in reverse. It is a situation our enemies will not enable us to enjoy forlong.
No comments:
Post a Comment